United States of America

Restaurants in Sag Harbor

3 restaurants in Sag Harbor recognised by Wine Spectator. The ones most guides agree on come first.

1. Baron's Cove

   1 guide · 31 W. Water St., Sag Harbor, New York

   Baron's Cove brings beachfront American dining to Sag Harbor's West Water Street, with a Wine Spectator-recognized list and a full menu of seafood and BBQ.

2. Lulu Kitchen & Bar

   1 guide · 126 Main St., Sag Harbor, New York

   French-Mediterranean cooking fired over wood in the heart of Sag Harbor, with a Wine Spectator-recognized list and a team rooted in East End hospitality.

3. The American Hotel

   1 guide · 45 Main St., Sag Harbor, New York

   A Sag Harbor institution on Main Street, The American Hotel has held Wine Spectator's Grand Award since 1981 for its exceptional European seasonal cuisine.